Why Your Car Is Struggling To Change Gears? (Causes & Fixes!)


high rpm while driving automatic

You may ask yourself, perhaps even searching for “Car Struggling To Change Gears?”, haven’t you? Well, search no more. This question is more common than you think, especially among drivers experiencing seemingly inexplicable issues with their vehicle’s transmission.

So, why your car is struggling to change gears? There can be several reasons, such as worn-out clutch plates, low transmission fluid, or a damaged gearbox, which interfere with the smooth transitioning between gears in your car.

Reading this article will provide you with an in-depth understanding of these potential causes, along with their respective solutions. It’s the perfect guide to troubleshooting and resolving this frustrating automotive issue.

What Are Some Common Causes of Transmission Problems in Cars?

Transmission problems in cars can arise from a variety of factors, including low transmission fluid, worn-out clutch plates, and electronic failures. Addressing these issues promptly can prevent more severe damage and costly repairs.

Low Transmission Fluid:

The transmission fluid plays a pivotal role in ensuring the smooth operation of the transmission system. It lubricates, cools, and cleans the internal parts.

A low level of transmission fluid can lead to overheating, delayed gear shifts, and even transmission failure. Regularly checking and topping up the fluid can help prevent these issues.

Worn-Out Clutch Plates (For Manual Transmissions):

In manual transmission vehicles, the clutch plates are essential for changing gears. Over time, these plates can wear out, leading to difficulty in shifting gears.

A worn-out clutch can cause the transmission to slip or not engage properly. Replacing the clutch plates when signs of wear are evident can ensure smoother gear shifts.

Electronic Failures:

Modern vehicles rely heavily on electronics to control various functions, including the transmission system.

Faulty sensors or issues with the vehicle’s computer can lead to erratic gear shifts or the transmission not engaging at all. Regular diagnostics can help identify and rectify electronic issues before they escalate.

Clogged Transmission Filter:

The transmission filter helps keep the transmission fluid clean by trapping dirt and other contaminants. Over time, this filter can become clogged, restricting the flow of fluid. A clogged filter can lead to poor transmission performance and even damage. It’s essential to replace the filter at recommended intervals.

Damaged Torque Converter (For Automatic Transmissions):

In automatic transmissions, the torque converter plays a crucial role in connecting the engine to the transmission.

Issues with the torque converter, like damaged needle bearings, can lead to transmission problems. Symptoms include slipping gears and shuddering. Addressing torque converter issues promptly can prevent further damage.

External Interferences:

Sometimes, external factors can interfere with the transmission’s operation. Accidents or impacts can damage the transmission casing or misalign components. Regular inspections, especially after a significant impact, can help identify and rectify such issues.

Why Your Car Is Struggling To Change Gears?

Low transmission fluid

Importance of Transmission Fluid

Transmission fluid is a pivotal element in a vehicle’s transmission system. It not only lubricates the internal components but also provides the necessary hydraulic pressure for gear changes and dissipates the heat generated within the transmission.

Maintaining the right level of this fluid is crucial for the efficient and smooth operation of the transmission system.

Signs of Low Transmission Fluid

Several signs indicate a low transmission fluid level. These include difficulty or delay in shifting gears, gears that seem to slip or change without the driver’s input, unusual noises like grinding or whining from the transmission, overheating, and even visible fluid leaks beneath the vehicle.

Causes of Low Transmission Fluid

The reasons for this depletion can vary. It might be due to leaks in the transmission system, inadequate fluid levels post-service, prolonged use without a fluid change, or even the natural degradation of the fluid over time.

Worn Clutch (In Manual Transmission)

The Role of the Clutch in Gear Changes

In vehicles with a manual transmission, the clutch is instrumental in changing gears. It acts as the bridge, connecting and disconnecting the engine’s power from the transmission.

The clutch comprises a pressure plate, friction disc, and flywheel. When the driver presses the clutch pedal, it releases the friction disc from the flywheel, allowing for a gear change. Once the pedal is released, the clutch engages, linking the engine and transmission again.

Signs of a Worn Clutch

You might find it hard to shift gears, especially if there’s a grinding noise. The clutch pedal might feel unusually soft or spongy.

In some cases, the clutch might slip, causing the engine to rev without a corresponding increase in the vehicle’s speed. A distinct burning smell from the clutch area is another telltale sign.

Causes of Clutch Wear

This wear can be attributed to regular usage, aggressive driving habits, or even poor clutch practices like riding the clutch pedal.

Transmission Wear or Damage

Signs of Transmission Wear or Damage

The health of the transmission is paramount for smooth driving. Signs of wear or damage include difficulty in shifting gears, noises when changing gears, fluid leaks, or even a burnt smell from the transmission. In some scenarios, the gears might slip, or there could be a sudden power loss while driving.

Causes of Transmission Wear or Damage

Such wear or damage can arise from various sources. Low or degraded transmission fluid can increase friction within the transmission, leading to wear. Regular use, overheating due to poor heat dissipation, driving habits, or even manufacturing defects can contribute to this wear.

Electronic or Sensor Issues

The Role of Electronics in Gear Changes

Modern vehicles, especially those with automatic transmissions, are heavily reliant on electronics for gear changes. These systems monitor various parameters to determine the best time to shift gears.

Electronic control modules (ECMs) or transmission control modules (TCMs) oversee this, using data from sensors to manage the transmission’s internal components.

Symptoms of Electronic or Sensor Issues

However, issues can arise. Erratic shifting, harsh gear changes, or transmission slipping are common symptoms. In some cases, the transmission might go into a “limp mode,” limiting the gear range to prevent further damage. Illuminated warning lights on the dashboard can also indicate problems.

Root Causes of Electronic Problems

These issues can stem from faulty sensors, damaged wiring, software glitches in the ECM or TCM, or even external factors like water damage or extreme temperatures. Proper diagnosis and repair by a qualified technician are essential to rectify these problems.

Fixes for Gear Change Struggles

Checking and Maintaining Transmission Fluid Levels

How to Check Transmission Fluid Levels

To check your vehicle’s transmission fluid levels, follow these steps: Park the vehicle on a level surface and engage the parking brake. Start the engine and let it warm up.

Shift through all gears, then return to “Park” or “Neutral”. Locate the transmission dipstick, pull it out, wipe it clean, reinsert it, and then check the fluid level. The fluid should be translucent red and free of debris. If it’s dark or has a burnt smell, consider a fluid change.

When and How to Change Transmission Fluid

The frequency of fluid changes varies by vehicle and driving conditions. Typically, it’s every 30,000 to 60,000 miles. To change the fluid: Park on a level surface and engage the parking brake.

Jack up the vehicle, locate the fluid pan and drain the fluid. Replace the old transmission filter, clean the pan, and reinstall it. Lower the vehicle, fill it with the recommended fluid, and then check the level again.

Replacing or Repairing a Worn Clutch

Signs that a Clutch Needs Replacement or Repair

Signs of a worn clutch include difficulty shifting gears, a soft or spongy clutch pedal, a slipping clutch, and a burning smell from the clutch area.

The Process of Clutch Replacement or Repair

Replacing or repairing a clutch is intricate. Disconnect the battery, remove obstructions, support the engine and transmission, and then remove the transmission.

Remove the old clutch assembly, inspect the flywheel, and install the new clutch. Reinstall the transmission, reconnect components, and test the clutch operation.

Repairing or Replacing Damaged Transmission Components

How to Diagnose Transmission Damage

Diagnosing transmission damage requires expertise. A technician can read fault codes from the vehicle’s ECM or TCM. A visual inspection can also reveal leaks, damaged components, or unusual wear patterns.

Repairing vs. Replacing a Damaged Transmission

Deciding between repair or replacement depends on the damage extent, repair costs, and the vehicle’s condition. Repairing individual components might be cost-effective, but extensive damage might warrant a full transmission replacement.

Troubleshooting and Fixing Electronic or Sensor Issues

How to Diagnose Electronic or Sensor Issues

Diagnosing electronic or sensor issues requires a qualified technician. They’ll read fault codes from the ECM or TCM and may test sensors and wiring to identify problems.

Common Fixes for Electronic or Sensor Issues

Fixes might include replacing faulty sensors, repairing damaged wiring, updating the ECM or TCM software, or addressing external factors like corrosion. Working with an experienced technician ensures a successful resolution.

Why is My Car Having a Hard Time Changing Gears?

A car’s difficulty in changing gears can be attributed to low transmission fluid, worn-out components, or electronic issues. Addressing these problems promptly ensures smoother gear transitions and prolongs the transmission’s lifespan.

Transmission Fluid Levels

Transmission fluid acts as the lifeblood of the transmission system. Its primary role is to lubricate, provide hydraulic pressure, and cool the system.

When the fluid level is insufficient, the transmission can’t function optimally, leading to noticeable delays or difficulties during gear shifts. Regularly checking and maintaining the right fluid level can prevent many gear change issues.

Worn Out Components

Every component within the transmission system has a lifespan. Over time, gears, bearings, or synchros can wear out, making gear changes challenging or even noisy.

This wear can be accelerated by aggressive driving or lack of maintenance. Regular inspections and timely replacements can ensure smoother gear transitions.

Electronic Malfunctions

In today’s technologically advanced vehicles, electronics play a significant role in managing the transmission. Sensors and modules monitor and control gear changes.

However, any malfunction in these electronic components can disrupt normal operation, leading to erratic shifting or even getting stuck in a particular gear.

What to Do When Car Has Trouble Shifting Gears?

When a car exhibits gear shifting issues, it’s crucial to check the transmission fluid, drive gently, and consult a professional. These steps can prevent further damage and ensure safe driving.

Check Transmission Fluid

The first and foremost step is to inspect the transmission fluid. Its level and condition can directly impact the gear-shifting process. If the fluid is low, replenishing it can resolve many issues. However, if it appears dirty or burnt, a complete fluid change might be necessary.

Avoid Aggressive Driving

Until the root cause of the problem is identified and rectified, it’s wise to adopt a gentle driving approach. Avoid rapid accelerations, hard braking, and try to shift gears smoothly. This can prevent additional strain on the already compromised transmission system.

Seek Professional Help

If the problem persists or if you’re unsure about its severity, it’s always best to turn to experts. A professional mechanic or technician can provide a comprehensive diagnosis and recommend the necessary interventions. Their expertise can save you from potentially costly repairs in the future.

What are the Signs of Low Transmission Fluid?

Low transmission fluid can lead to delayed gear shifts, unusual noises, and overheating. Recognizing these signs early can prevent extensive transmission damage.

Delayed or Erratic Shifting

A clear indication of low transmission fluid is the difficulty experienced during gear shifts. The transmission might respond slower than usual or even shift unpredictably. This erratic behavior can make driving challenging and potentially unsafe.

Unusual Noises

A transmission operating with insufficient fluid can produce distinct sounds. Drivers might hear grinding, whining, or clunking, especially during gear changes. These noises signify a lack of lubrication inside the transmission, which can lead to accelerated wear.

Overheating

Transmission fluid plays a dual role: lubrication and cooling. When its level drops, the transmission can overheat, manifesting as a burnt smell or even smoke. Continuous operation in such a state can cause irreversible damage.

Why is My Car Struggling to Accelerate in Low Gears?

Struggles with acceleration in low gears can stem from transmission slippage, engine issues, or external factors. Identifying the cause is crucial for effective resolution.

Transmission Slippage

One potential cause for acceleration issues is transmission slippage. This occurs when the transmission doesn’t engage properly, leading to a delay in power delivery. In low gears, this slippage can be particularly noticeable, making the car feel sluggish.

Engine Performance Issues

Sometimes, the problem lies not with the transmission but with the engine. Faulty spark plugs, clogged fuel injectors, or air intake issues can hinder acceleration. Even in low gears, if the engine isn’t delivering adequate power, the car will struggle to pick up speed.

External Factors

On other occasions, external factors might be the culprits. Dragging brakes, under-inflated tires, or a clogged exhaust system can all impede acceleration. Addressing these external issues can often restore the car’s acceleration capabilities.

How Can I Diagnose a Transmission Problem in My Car?

Diagnosing transmission problems involves visual inspections, listening for anomalies, and using diagnostic tools. A systematic approach can pinpoint the issue effectively.

Visual Inspection

Begin with a thorough visual check. Look for any signs of leaks, damaged components, or unusual wear patterns on the transmission. Often, visual cues can provide valuable insights into the underlying problem.

Listen and Feel

Your senses can be powerful diagnostic tools. Tune in to any unusual noises during gear changes or vibrations that weren’t present before. These can be indicative of issues within the transmission system. Feeling hesitations during shifts or any jerkiness can also provide clues.

Diagnostic Tools

In the age of technology, many cars come equipped with advanced electronic systems. Diagnostic tools can read fault codes related to the transmission, offering insights into potential problems. These tools interface with the vehicle’s onboard computer, retrieving data that can be invaluable for pinpointing issues.

What are the Signs that My Car’s Transmission Needs Repair?

Recognizing signs like difficulty in shifting, unusual noises, warning lights, and fluid leaks can indicate that your car’s transmission requires attention. Timely repairs can prevent more extensive damage and costly replacements.

Difficulty in Shifting Gears

One of the most evident signs of transmission in distress is trouble during gear shifts. The car might refuse to go into certain gears, slip out of gear unexpectedly, or there might be noticeable delays during shifts.

Unusual Sounds

A transmission in need of repair can be quite vocal. Sounds like grinding, whining, or clunking, especially during gear changes, are red flags. These noises can indicate internal wear or damage that needs addressing.

Warning Lights

Modern vehicles come equipped with an array of warning lights. If your dashboard lights up with a transmission or check engine light, it’s a clear sign that something’s amiss. These lights are triggered by the car’s computer when it detects anomalies in the system.

Fluid Leaks

Transmission fluid should remain within the system. If you notice puddles or spots of red or brownish fluid under your car, it’s a sign of a leak. Regularly inspecting your usual parking spots can help you catch such leaks early on.

Related Articles

Read more >> Is A Loose Gear Stick Dangerous? (Simply Explained!)

Read more >> Why Is A Transmission Delay Going Into Drive? (Explained!)

Read more >> What Is Hill Start Assist On Automatic Transmission?

Read more >> Do You Have Problems After Rebuilding A Transmission?

Read more >> What’s The Difference Between “Hill Hold” and “Hill Assist”?

Conclusion

Understanding the causes of gear change struggles in your car and how to address them is crucial for maintaining your vehicle’s performance and longevity.

Regular maintenance, including checking and changing transmission fluid, can help prevent many common issues.

If you experience any warning signs or symptoms of transmission problems, seek the help of a qualified technician to diagnose and repair the issue promptly. By taking proactive steps to care for your vehicle’s transmission, you can help ensure a smoother and more enjoyable driving experience.

Reference Source:

https://www.cbac.com/grand-parkway/media-center/blog/2017/march/transmission-trouble-10-warning-signs-you-need-r/

John M.

John is an automotive technician, technical writer. He has held a lifelong passion for vehicles.

Recent Posts

error: Content is protected !!